Used 2014 M5 vs Used 2014 CLS 63 AMG

[pjhz21c]

Hello guys,

As the title states, my lease is almost up and am considering between these two options. (I'm also considering leasing a new 2015 M5 with pull ahead program but will rule this option out for this post..)

I do have a 2014 911 S as a weekend car so this new purchase will be a daily driver.

It seems like the used 2014 CLS 63 that has about similar miles (~10k) as used 2014 M5 is bit higher in price.(Both high 70k~ low 80k range)

Which option would you prefer? Why?

Thanks in advance!

[swanson]

Just on looks a lone the CLS would be my choice. I believe the performance is very similar. The CLS63 is a sexy looking car.

[wisesoul]

On an M5 forum, you're bound to get biased answers lol. I've driven the CLS 63 and liked it quite a bit. The chassis is a bit floaty for me and the rear headroom is barely tolerable, but great ride. Power wise, they are about even. M5 walks it in the triple digits, at least when I raced one.

[M6-Coupe]

Is CLS63 S model? and 4matic?

[Schnell_1]

I always compared the M5 to the E63, and the M6 Gran Coupe to the CLS63. You'll find a little more luxury, style, and traction (AMG-S variant) with the CLS, but you'll encounter more sportiness, improved shifting (an actual DCT vs MB's MCT), and more of a driver's experience with the M5.

Drive them both - there are tons of options in a 90 mile radius...

[pjhz21c]

Thanks for your opinions guys! I really appreciate it.

I did actually look into the AMG-S 4matic models too. However, they were about ~10k more expensive than the M5 (non-comp) while the non-S models were ~5k higher in price.
I wanted to compare both cars with as similar options as possible and get opinions from you guys. Also, I wasn't sure if the extra ~5k was worth the S and 4matic option because it will be my DD and I already have 911 S for weekend driving.

I have only test driven used 2012 CLS 63 few days ago but have never driven the M5.

Although it is not a crucial deciding factor, I would also prefer one that depreciates slower than the other. (I plan on keeping it for about 3 years with around 10k miles/yr)

Thanks!

[Knicks_fan2]

Originally Posted by pjhz21c

Thanks for your opinions guys! I really appreciate it.

I did actually look into the AMG-S 4matic models too. However, they were about ~10k more expensive than the M5 (non-comp) while the non-S models were ~5k higher in price.
I wanted to compare both cars with as similar options as possible and get opinions from you guys. Also, I wasn't sure if the extra ~5k was worth the S and 4matic option because it will be my DD and I already have 911 S for weekend driving.

I have only test driven used 2012 CLS 63 few days ago but have never driven the M5.

Although it is not a crucial deciding factor, I would also prefer one that depreciates slower than the other. (I plan on keeping it for about 3 years with around 10k miles/yr)

Thanks!

I bet they depreciate similarly but M5 lease deals are fairly excellent right now (likely were better before the new year). I can't comment on the ride of the CLS because it was never an option for me given that I wanted three rear seats in case that matters to you op.